007 Number 7: Thoughts on Robert Pattinson as James Bond.
Is James Bond even still relevant in the 2020s? Perhaps, but he'll be a harder sell than before.
I guess I count as a James Bond fan. I was declared as such recently by a YouTube channel called Bondboard, which recently did a reaction video to my video “Bond in Context: Quantum of Solace.” Therefore, as an officially-anointed fan, I guess I’m expected to have thoughts on the decision, announced earlier this week, that Eon Productions has cast Robert Pattinson as the spy hero for the next film, to be directed by Denny Villeneuve. I do have thoughts, but they’re more on the state of Bond in general in the 2020s than they are on Pattinson himself. In any event I thought it’d make an interesting article.
First: I have no strong feelings about Robert Pattinson one way or another. It was announced fairly late that he was even in the running, but when it was I felt it was likely the Eon team would choose him, as he’s the biggest star among those who were said to be considered, at least seriously. He’s suave, he’s British, he looks good in a tuxedo and having played Batman it’s clear he’s at home with big action pictures. I first saw Pattinson about 20 years ago in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire—no, I don’t patronize anything related to the Potter franchise anymore, since doing so would support J.K. Rowling’s unconscionable transphobia—and I thought he was quite talented. I also very much liked him in the deliciously strange 2019 film The Lighthouse, a two-hander in which Pattinson more than held his own against Willem Dafoe. I’ll reserve judgment for when I actually see him onscreen as Bond, but I have no reason to think he won’t do quite adequately, if not brilliantly. I remember the judgy backlash on the then fairly-new internet back in 2005 when Daniel Craig was cast, and he turned out to be amazing. So, let’s wait to see how he does in the role before we decide whether or not he’s a good fit for the character.
My generational identity is such that it’s hard to pin down who is “my” classic James Bond. While I started watching the films as a kid, I was all of 13 when Roger Moore’s final film, A View to a Kill came out. I loved Timothy Dalton, who first debuted in The Living Daylights in 1987, but he only did two films and it’s not really accurate to say that I “grew up with” the Dalton Bond in the same way that people slightly older than me grew up with Moore, and those born later grew up with Pierce Brosnan or Daniel Craig. While I think Dalton is the strongest actor, in terms of pure craft, ever to have played the role, it’s sort of weird even for me to anoint him as my “favorite” James Bond. People forget that Dalton’s portrayal was 20 years ahead of its time. He played Bond as a nihilistic assassin, a man who hates his job, hates his life but doesn’t know how to do anything else. Audiences weren’t ready for that in the ‘80s, but they definitely were post-9/11 when Daniel Craig came on the scene. Timothy Dalton walked so Daniel Craig could run.

I guess a bigger question is whether we still need James Bond, or whether the character makes any sense in the modern context. I was perfectly happy with the idea that No Time to Die, Craig’s last outing which came out in 2021, would be the last-ever Bond film—spoiler alert, Bond dies at the end of that one—but I suspected it wouldn’t be simply because there’s more money to be made from the franchise. But let’s not forget that the character as created by writer Ian Fleming was a reflection of Britain in the early 1950s. (The first novel, Casino Royale, was published in 1953). If you read the books, Bond comes off as a highly unpleasant man. Even if you can get past the fact that he’s basically a hit man for the British crown, Bond as written in the novels is a raging misogynist, a racist, an alcoholic and drug addict (Benzedrine, an amphetamine mentioned often in the books, is his drug of choice), and works to prop up the exploitative system of the British Empire, which in the 1950s was dying rapidly. The sadistic and sadomasochistic dimensions of Fleming’s novels are also a little grotesque. That doesn’t mean they’re not fun adventures. They are. But Bond himself is, in a word, an asshole.
The movies have taken varying approaches to Bond’s character. Dalton and Craig leaned most heavily into Bond’s unpleasantness, while Roger Moore and Pierce Brosnan were just so affable that it was hard to take them seriously when they were called upon to kill people in cold blood. Sean Connery was incredibly suave but also an inveterate ass-kicker, and none of the other actors could really match that exact combination, though Craig came close. And the films rarely showed us the decay of British colonialism in the Cold War era, though we catch a few glimpses of it, especially in Dr. No, the first film, and surprisingly in Skyfall, released 50 years later. Fleming was obsessed with the decline of the British Empire. The films didn’t share that preoccupation. When Roger Moore was capering around dressed as a circus clown in Octopussy or Pierce Brosnan was driving literally an invisible car in Die Another Day, no one was thinking too much about Great Britain’s place in the world order.
Pattinson, though, will have a difficult job interpreting James Bond in our modern world, whether he realizes it or not. The first film in which he appears, perhaps in 2027 or 2028, will, astonishingly, be the first James Bond film to be made in the reign of a British monarch other than Elizabeth II. It will be only the second post-Brexit film. The Cold War, which was once the character Bond’s natural habitat, is a distant memory now. Pattinson was born in 1986, a toddler when the Berlin Wall came down, and a teenager at the time of 9/11. What is the UK’s place in the world now in the late 2020s? I don’t think the British themselves know. I have a couple of friends from the UK. They’re overwhelmingly concerned with keeping their jobs, getting medical care and paying their insanely high heating bills. None of them seem to have any attachment to or even awareness of the idea of Britain as a player of any kind on the world stage, even a faded or passé one. Maybe older people—the kind who voted for Brexit—pine for the days of the UK as an imperial world power, but I don’t personally know anyone who thinks that way. It seems like those desires are rapidly becoming part of the past.

I think this leaves James Bond in a bit of a quandary. If there’s no British Empire left to defend and the UK’s global ambitions are vastly downsized from what they were even a quarter-century ago, what is Bond even doing out there? Over the past few films his ambitions have been greatly scaled-down from the days when he was literally saving the world from megalomaniacal villains, like Stromberg in The Spy Who Loved Me and Drax in Moonraker. I don’t even think the approach that Eon Productions took in 1995 with the reboot GoldenEye—which was sold with the tag line, “The world has changed, Bond hasn’t”—will work this time. It’s just too hard to make the obvious case for his relevance. Whatever story the first Robert Pattinson Bond film puts the character into will have an uphill climb to make that case.
Maybe all of this is leading toward the conclusion that the next James Bond picture should be a period piece. Just from the nature of the franchise, certain things will have to be true of that film. Pattinson is going to appear in a tuxedo, drink a martini, drive an Aston Martin, romance a beautiful woman and emit pithy one-liners after dispatching the villains. I guarantee all of those things will happen in the next Bond film. But if the story is set in, say, 1962, the filmmakers would have a vast and inviting playground to romp in and they’ll also eliminate the danger that seeing James Bond do these things in 2027 or 2028 will look a little tired, and they also won’t have to do anything corny to explain away the character’s death at the end of No Time to Die. Bond may be a relic of the past, but people will still pay to see him. I for one would love a period Bond picture and I’m sure I’m not alone. I hope this is the direction they decide to go.
Robert Pattinson will be the 7th actor to play James Bond in the official Eon Series. I for one welcome him to the role and wish him well. While honestly I’d be just fine if we lived in a world where the James Bond series ended in 2021, I can’t say I don’t have positive anticipation for the next chapter in the saga. As my own history writing stories has attested, sometimes a character is just too good to leave alone.
The Value Proposition
Why should you be reading this blog, or receiving it as a newsletter? This is why.
☕ If you appreciate what I do, buy me a virtual coffee from time-to-time to support my work. I know it seems small, but it truly helps.
📖 You could also buy my newest book.
🎓 Like learning? Find out what courses I’m currently offering at my website.
📽 More the visual type? Here is my YouTube channel with tons of free history videos.
Comments ()